Is Shatnez-Checking a Multi-Million Dollar Industry?
Rabbi Abadi of kashrut.org has long since decried kashrus as a "multi-million dollar industry." That is a whole discussion in and of itself, and one which I don't know nearly enough to comment on. But I've heard a little about shatnez, and I would like to speculate on the possibility of that being a big money-maker.
One of my rabbeim once said that shatnez-checking is not necessary, at least for American suits. He said that the suits that have shatnez in them are so miminal in quantity to the ones that don't that we can rely on a rov. He admitted that the Hugo Boss-type suits would require checking. But the likes of Perry Ellis and Nautica? Not necessary, he said.
I think the shatnez checkers are useful in preventing people who buy fancy suits from transgressing the lavin. But when it comes to cheap American suits, do we really need to check them? After all, if we rely on a rove, we're fine! We're off the hook!
Let's say one would rely on the gemara's principles of rov and kol d'parish mayruba parish to eat a piece of meat. If the piece of meat is, in actuality, treif, was the guy over an aveira? No! He relied upon a rov, and once you do that, you're fine.
So for the purposes of full disclosure, why don't the shatnez companies say that if you get a Stanley Blacker suit, you're automatically fine? Instead, they advertise of the horrible chumros of shatnez, instead of the possible kulos involved. (One lab had a hat pasted on the wall, with a label saying "a young boy wearing this hat complained of headaches. Turned out, the hat had shatnez in it, which was causing the headaches!") And for a large family buying their children suits for yom tov, shouldn't they be spared the heavy expense of shatnez checking, especially if there's what to rely on?
Perhaps the mentality that "if someone wears shatnez, even if they're relying upon a rov, the tumah of the aveirah is still there!" comes into play here. And did they even have shatnez labs in Europe? Or is it a new thing?
One of my rabbeim once said that shatnez-checking is not necessary, at least for American suits. He said that the suits that have shatnez in them are so miminal in quantity to the ones that don't that we can rely on a rov. He admitted that the Hugo Boss-type suits would require checking. But the likes of Perry Ellis and Nautica? Not necessary, he said.
I think the shatnez checkers are useful in preventing people who buy fancy suits from transgressing the lavin. But when it comes to cheap American suits, do we really need to check them? After all, if we rely on a rove, we're fine! We're off the hook!
Let's say one would rely on the gemara's principles of rov and kol d'parish mayruba parish to eat a piece of meat. If the piece of meat is, in actuality, treif, was the guy over an aveira? No! He relied upon a rov, and once you do that, you're fine.
So for the purposes of full disclosure, why don't the shatnez companies say that if you get a Stanley Blacker suit, you're automatically fine? Instead, they advertise of the horrible chumros of shatnez, instead of the possible kulos involved. (One lab had a hat pasted on the wall, with a label saying "a young boy wearing this hat complained of headaches. Turned out, the hat had shatnez in it, which was causing the headaches!") And for a large family buying their children suits for yom tov, shouldn't they be spared the heavy expense of shatnez checking, especially if there's what to rely on?
Perhaps the mentality that "if someone wears shatnez, even if they're relying upon a rov, the tumah of the aveirah is still there!" comes into play here. And did they even have shatnez labs in Europe? Or is it a new thing?
44 Comments:
At three dollars a suit i doubt it is a multi million dollar industry.
If every frum Jewish male and female gives every suit and dress in for testing, it adds up.
Plus, they charge a ton to fix suits when they pull out the shatnez. Why don't they just tell me to go to a tailor, where I can get the job done for half the price?
Their are those that believe that one who wears a suit that contains shatnez while davening will not have his prayers answered. This is even if the shatnez is muttar al yedei rove. I can understand why that would make one want to be stringent.
Anonymous said...
At three dollars a suit i doubt it is a multi million dollar industry.
Where I live it's five dollars
Josh: just curious: what's the mekor for that? A gemara? A chassidish thing?
If I'm not mistaken, a chassidish yid started shatnez testing in America. And that would fit right in with what you said.
And considering every frum person seems to get their suits checked, I guess we can add this to list of "chassidishization of the litvish," a topic that Harry Maryles has discussed on a few occasions.
Definitely not chasidish. I think I may have seen it in sharei teshuva
But Josh, we don't pasken based on the spirit of the law. IOW, it's a chumra.
That's why I used the words
"I can understand why that would make one want to be stringent."
In that case, let the rabbis and shatnez checkers let the people know that American suits need not be checked, but if you want to be machmir then fine. If not, no need.
But don't deceive by implying that it MUST be checked.
Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!
10mg monoket Visa/Mastercard/Amex/eCheck nirdosh Sale ashwagandha Cheap serevent Order gyne-lotrimin Pharmacy septilin
use of clomid in men | clomid 100 - buy clomid online safely, cheap clomid pills
how long does clomid take to work | purchase clomid - buy clomid uk, nolvadex clomid pct dosage
chances of clomid working first time | http://cheapclomidonline.jimdo.com/#49867 - where to buy clomid online safely, cycle length on clomid
[b][url=http://www.bestlouisvuittonukstore.co.uk/]louis vuitton handbags[/url][/b] The initial issue that you should consider is definitely the cost of your purse you need to acquire. Before you decide to commence procuring you ought to have a excellent concept as to just how much money you can afford to pay for to spend. Truth be told, there are numerous purses that expenses in surplus of $1,000.
[b][url=http://www.cheapuggbootssalenow.co.uk/]ugg boots cheap[/url][/b] Girls enjoy bags coupled with tote bags along with especially if it truly is some type of labeled carry as an illustration Lv, some could typically be for the Seventh shangri-la. Bettering a proper LV originator scenario delivers surplus form for the closet and it really is also a fresh vital dietary supplement for your goods sequence. The exact Lv type is small for structure, miracles, style and sophistication.
On top of that to regularly utilizing the software program, it's important to correct the software program when it can make a slip-up. (You already know the poor dog routine--show him the paper following he piddles for the kitchen floor and hope that he learns from his oversight.) You'll be able to make your corrections either while you are dictating or after you have got accomplished your document. This need to be done so that the computer software isn't going to frequently make the same blunder..
[b][url=http://www.saleuggbootsstore.co.uk/]cheap ugg boots uk[/url][/b] Gucci Purely natural Red Prevalent Eco-friendly Bow has become reinterpreted. for instance Ould - Corinna Clutches, however deciding upon the best serious clutches. This type of company you just payment in your case to apperceive that you may possibly serenity the web broker that you are extramarital affairs by way of, There are several online purses stores to choose by means of.
Using the development in expertise and on the internet outlets our lives have became substantially less difficult than prior to. Now with all the enable of on the web retailers, you may virtually get everything you wish, just by clicking. Online searching actually offers you the at ease practical experience..
[b][url=http://www.salelouisvuittonbagsus.com/]louis vuitton bags[/url][/b] All through second can be the Chanel three. Fifty-five classic quilted just as before, which is usually something from the unique sort of Coco Chanel she is. Motivated by quilt-making with each other with Jockey layers, Chanel two. An additional central element that your family members wish to find out more details on glimpse and for to the an company chair could potentially be the again top adjustment. As for it can be absurd to find out more on as an example envision of operating powering an all in one desktop laptop sitting throughout the a multi operate chair lacking back preserving. While your friends and family should really stay very clear having to do with heading to generally be the ergonomic chair to ensure that you've got specially in thickness again supports,an all in a single changeable ergonomic lumbar help will fret about pretty affordable pricing..
hcg or clomid | order clomid no prescription - purchase clomid no prescription, side effects clomid
ovulation pain on clomid | http://buy-clomid-in-usa.webs.com/#19468 - buy clomid online canada, men clomid
1qMtx ghd hair straightener
fEcy michael kors outlet
xZsj ghd
5tXof ugg boots sale uk
3pBai ghd hair
4bAzw ghd flat iron
fRhg ugg boots on sale
aQvj michael kors handbags
6wAjf GHD Australia
4cUhm burberry outlet
1yTct bottes ugg pas cher
2uUdq ghd nz sale
8oHqc louis vuitton handbags
0eCqp michael kors sale
5gKnf cheap ghd straighteners
4wIji ugg uk
3bMbc cheap nfl jerseys
5rYst michael kors outlet online
3rLzi ghd
4lZhc cheap uggs
uBdg ghd
kNwa cheap uggs
jFwm michael kors outlet
6oJpg ugg boots
6xOdd chi
1vBgc michael kors bags
1bYbx nfl jerseys
7yTsy ghd nz
4lTxv north face jackets
4jGvr comprar ugg online
4vZrn ghd mk4
9uPsk michael kors purses
5mFgr cheap nfl jerseys
6lJva ghd
0sKjp cheap ugg boots
sildenafil citrate cheap viagra pills free shipping - pink viagra for women- side effects
viagra for sale best place order viagra online - how to buy viagra
buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg compared to percocet - buy tramadol health solutions network
ovulation pain on clomid | http://buyclomidcheap.webs.com/#23931 - clomid tabs, clomid dosing
clomid generic name | buy clomid online uk - clomid online, clomid day 2
clomid symptoms after ovulation | [url=http://purchaseclomid.jimdo.com/#31506]generic clomid[/url] - how to buy clomid online, eled clomiphene citrate clomid side effects
soma drug soma muscle relaxer controlled substance - soma drug directions
buy cialis online cheap cialis black - cialis daily dose cost
carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol soma vanadom - soma carisoprodol buy
euro phentermine 37.5 without prescription - phentermine 37.5 http://www.tripstoireland.org/#phentermine-37.5 , [url=http://www.tripstoireland.org/#phentermine-online ]phentermine online [/url]
cialis online generic cialis vs real cialis - how much cialis daily
cialis online safe place order cialis - buy cialis arizona
buy klonopin online klonopin withdrawal relief - klonopin vs xanax side effects
http://landvoicelearning.com/#97734 buy tramadol cod next day delivery - buy tramadol legit
buy tramadol online tramadol online no prescription cod - withdrawal from tramadol addiction
klonopin for anxiety prozac klonopin side effects - klonopin generic same
order clonazepam klonopin dosage for children - klonopin lunch free
http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#9183 klonopin grapefruit juice - what is klonopin high
michael kors outlet online, hogan outlet, converse pas cher, michael kors outlet, burberry handbags, guess pas cher, nike blazer pas cher, nike air max uk, coach outlet store online, hollister uk, true religion outlet, nike tn, michael kors outlet online, hollister pas cher, kate spade, north face, uggs outlet, coach purses, replica handbags, uggs outlet, ralph lauren uk, polo lacoste, michael kors outlet online, sac hermes, nike air max uk, true religion jeans, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet, mulberry uk, nike air force, north face uk, timberland pas cher, sac vanessa bruno, new balance, burberry outlet, lululemon canada, nike roshe run uk, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet online, abercrombie and fitch uk, oakley pas cher, ray ban pas cher, nike air max, ray ban uk, vans pas cher, coach outlet, michael kors, michael kors outlet
من منا لا يحتاج إلى سباك يقوم بكافة أعمال السباكة الخاصة بالمنازل والشقق والفلل والقصور، كما أن الشركة تعتمد في أداء عملها على مجموعة متميزة من عمال ومهندسين محترفين في أعمال السباكة المتطورة، فشركتنا تحرص على أن يتم تدريب عمالها على استخدامهم لأحدث المعدات والتقنيات الحديثة التي تساعد على كشف مكان مشكلة السباكة، أو كشف تسرب مياه من أي نوع، لذا عند حدوث أي مشكلة يجب أن يتم اللجوء إلى شركتنا على الفور فنحن الشركة الوحيدة التي تمتلك القدرة على كشف وتصليح جميع المشكلات الخاصة بأعمال السباكة.
سباك بالمدينة المنورة
كهربائي بالمدينة المنورة
دهان بالمدينة المنورة
نجار بالمدينة المنورة
معلم سباك بجدة
معلم كهربائي بجدة
شركة عزل في الاحساء
العزل باستخدام مواد الفوم هو من الأكثر انتشاراً وطلباً من العملاء في الوقت الحالي نظراً لأنه لديه إمكانيات جبارة ورائعة للحفاظ على الأسطح والجدران من العوامل المناخية المختلفة كالرطوبة وعوامل الحرارة والرياح وغيرها، كما أنه مفيد جداً لمنع دخول الحشرات والقوارض لذلك فإن العزل يقدم حماية متكاملة للمنازل والمباني، ومن أهم فوائد العزل بالفوم انه يقدم خاصية العزل المائي والحراري معاً فقديما كان يتم تركيب العول الحراري والعزل المائي كلاً منهم على حده ولكن الآن يمكنكم الحصول على عازل واحد وبأقل وأرخص الأسعار لذلك تعاونوا معنا الآن عبر أرقامنا ولا تترددوا للحظة لأنكم لن تجدوا أفضل منا على الإطلاق.
pandora jewelry
westbrook shoes
supreme clothing
kyrie 7
off white
golden goose
curry 8
hermes
moncler jackets
golden goose sneakers
ابو الهول
دهان رخيص في الشارقة
تلميع سيراميك وبورسلين باالشارقة
الامانة كلين
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض ام القيوين
شركة مكافحة بق الفراش ام القيوين
Post a Comment
<< Home